Sorry bro. But I feel like I've had a bullseye on my back lately and overreacted.
As for your question.
This is highly debatable and not something that has a while lot of studies behind it, so I'm going by logic and personal experience. One would think there's no need for PCT because you never have low levels of T if you're on replacement. But I do believe it's good for the body to try and produce some test on it's own. This is where I believe HCG is beneficial and I know there's going to be some argument about that as well. I should mention that I believe PCT in general is often a lot of smoke and mirrors. The body must recover naturally and there are things to do to help it along the way. (As a matter of fact I would BRIDGE in that). But when you use a drug like Clomid, even if it works, you need to come off the drug. This is also my argument about SARMS. Guys would go on SARMS and say, "Hey! I didn't have any shutdown! " Sure, because they're essentially still on. The SARMS did;t help in recovery. It just delayed it.
Of course, once you're on HRT for years, you will be completely shut down, but even there, for nothing else but the cosmetic reason of avoiding too much testicular atrophy, some PCT can't hurt. In fact, I'm working on a natural supplement that will do just that. Yes -- give you bigger balls. (To an extent). To some guys it doesn't matter, to other it does.