todd has touched on this a bit in his own life,
I STILL get people saying “I thought you just eat meat” when they see me eat a slice of pizza at a party. It’s the same people who said that at the last party. I haven’t been a strict carnivore for almost five years
If I did it again I wouldn’t even tell anyone unless it directly affected them. I would just fast and binge meat and say I wasn’t hungry.
I think about this stuff all the time, like the fat lady at the party that thinks I look the way I do because of fake liver king reasons lol, and then she has cognitive dissonance when I eat a donut. I look the way I do because of the cumulative effect of my entire life (of course the gear REALLY put the polish on, put the size on, and the unmistakable accents like delts popping out, and veins, only gear does that). I can eat like shit for a day, a week even, and it will barely effect my look, sometimes I’ll even look better.
But I definitely think you’ve got to get to that point somehow before you can get away with it. I’ve heard that the human body like to create “set points”. Like if you’re 25% body fat, there are homeostatic processes in your body that will constantly adjust to keep you there. So if your energy expenditure goes up, your appetite goes up, even though your body is carrying 10s of thousands of calories around. And if your caloric intake goes down, your body will slow down, literally you will feel lazy, you might even just fidget less and not even realize that your 250 calorie deficit is being absorbed by a lower metabolic rate.
So the trick is to hack your body into keeping a high metabolism in a deficit. This seems true to my experience, even if it was an accident. My whole life I would just eat as much as I could when I was able to and my activity levels are often pretty much maxed out. And when I’m not doing a damn thing I just don’t really eat. And many times I’m forced to exert myself quite a bit when I’m truly hungry, which isn’t great for holding muscle but it forces your mitochondria to be very efficient at making energy. I have lived a pretty extreme lifestyle.
I found a few pictures of myself from riiiiight before I started gear. I had been carnivore for a few years, and was about a year into lifting but had been effectively crippled from injury for the previous five years or so, ummm maybe longer. Maybe eight years but I had been on the mend for two or three.
You can see, I was fit, but no one would have accused me of juicing. Before I was injured I was 195 pounds natty, still with abs. Bigger than I am now and stronger in many ways. In these pics, maybe 165.